Even though I know it shouldn't...
I mean, really now, who cares about one little podcasting network anyway? In the grand scheme of things such concerns are less than trivial if not inconsequential. If a beloved icon of tech journalism like Leo Laporte chooses to delude himself while his Rome is burning what business is it of ours if he chooses to believe otherwise?
If TWIT vanished from the landscape of Internet content the number of people who actually cared would be lower than the percentage of LGBT's in the Tea Party.
...and the king of Tech punditry would do just fine thank you...
Over the past few months I've continued to witness a sea change at TWIT with the most obvious symptom an exodus of popular hosts and programming. In their place bizarre additions like Marketing Mavericks, a show based on sucking up to the kind of people who dreamed up click-through ads and stadiums named after cell-phone companies.
And then there's the ads! Oh those god awful ads! Where do they find these products??
Of course, not everybody agrees with me...
"I'm good enough, I'm smart enough, and doggone it people like me!" Stuart Smiley
If you can sift through the barrage of delusional self-affirmation and staunch denial of anything contrarian that pervades today's TWIT, there are still gems to be found on the network.
Shows like This Week in Law, This week in Enterprise Tech, Windows Weekly and the grand old man of the group This Week In Tech still shine. Unfortunately, to find them you'll have to ignore the cognitive dissonance that promotes Tech News Today (TNT) as still being relevant or Floss Weekly and Ham Nation as being interesting. Incidentally, after almost 6 months, TNT still consistently ranks far behind Tom Merritt's Daily Tech News show and has yet to break into the top 10 on most ranking authorities.
With the often abrupt departures of popular talent like Tom Merritt, Brian Brushwood and even Iyaz Akhtar, the void that remains has been filled (with varying degrees of success) by hosts like:
Father Robert Ballecer, the affable and upbeat "digital Jesuit" who is increasingly ever present and likely heir to TWIT if not for his "other" job.
Chad Johnson, OMGCHAD and newest Laporte protege' who is often called upon to beta test new programming like the short-lived This Week in YouTube and RedditUP (currently in beta.)
Sara Lane, a stalwart TWIT personality and second only to Laporte in the sheer volume of shows she hosts. As one of the few remaining alumni from Laporte's TechTV days, Lane appears loyal to Laporte but one has to wonder if those convictions have been tested since the surprise departure of so many TWIT colleagues from the network.
And of course, Laporte himself who recently took back hosting duties of TWIT's tech review show Before You Buy after former host and producer Shannon Morse left TWIT's full time employ.
Shannon Morse, the contractor, now only appears once a week on TWIT as co-host of Coding 101 with Fr. Robert Ballecer.
Morse, known most prominently from Darren Kitchen's Hak 5 was a recent addition to the network in the past year. Her decision to trade a full time gig at TWIT to be a contract host for one show (while doing at least 2 others for Revision 3) can only be viewed as a foot out the door.
The only time a full time employee converts to a contractor these days is when somebody is on their way out and Laporte taking back hosting duties of Before You Buy underscores just how "out" Morse really is.
But let's be fair here. While TWIT's apparent missteps are beginning to border on habitual, it's not entirely their fault. Take a look at those same podcast rankings that are so damning to TNT and you'll find a saturated landscape. Everybody and their brother seems to have a tech podcast. Couple that with the fact that the novelty has worn off. There's very little new information out there and "revolutionary" is just a marketing buzzword. Technology isn't "magical" anymore and even your grandmother can use an IPad.
Go ahead, check The Verge, TechCrunch or even TNT (if you can stay awake) and the content is without fail a daily march of ad nauseam reviews of yet another "revolutionary" smart device. Lest we forget the constant security breaches of well known web properties and tech pundits desperately inflating their copy by reviving long dead adjectives like, "plaudits."
Not very exciting...
Short term gain leading to long term consequences.
That TWIT advertising has increasingly strayed from a tech focus to products like razors, jewelry and snacks may be an indication that tech just isn't that sexy anymore. Unfortunately, it also frequently results in content straying from technology to heated debates over single versus multi-blade razors.
Viewer's of TWIT could likely care less about razors, underwear and harvest rice sticks when they're watching Security Now or Windows Weekly. At times even the hosts seem annoyed as they hawk often ridiculous and contextually irrelevant wares. With an average of 2 to 4 live ad reads per TWIT show, anything that strays from the content runs the risk of losing an easily fickle audience.
Where TWIT may once have been a destination rivaling its progenitor, TechTV, in the past year it's become more akin to G4. In case you don't get the analogy, G4 began as a cable channel focused on video games and gaming culture and ended with a schedule largely consisting of Cops reruns and infomercials.
TWIT's bizarre programming changes, a trend of topically irrelevant advertising and exodus of talent paint a dark picture of the network's future.
It's high time ego and hubris take a back seat.